There are several differences between classic noir and neo noir films. Some of them can be that the classic noir was in black and white versus neo noir in color, noir films were created in the early '40s and associated with with World War II while neo noir movies were produced in the late 20th century. Obviously the scenarios changed, while noir has a lack of space, hotel rooms or urban streets, might because the budget. Neo noir is film in places with more room and its lines are based in real situations as political, social or general life. In addition, the narrative which is present in noir mode is not longer used for the modern noir films, the author of The Dark Past Keeps returning: Gender Themes in Neo-Noir, Heather borrows the quote "Form is fragmented, narratives are discontinuous, and absolute truth is meaningless" (Salim). I do know exactly why, but might be because the scenes are more understanding so the narrative is not necessary. Either classic noir and neo noir characters have different roles but the same freaky intention: manipulate with their emotions to accomplish their goal.
Noir male protagonist do everything for the femme fatale desires until both are destroyed for their own human nature. Neo noir story-tales apparently are based either to find how to be a real man or how the roles of man an woman has affected femaleness. Some of the actors are not longer guided for a woman instead they are driven for a male. Like in the case of Fight Club, where Jack in his intent to avoid Marla, he finds himself being guide by Tyler, to whom he sees as a teacher of his life. Moreover, Tyler has the theory of "Manhood is lost because we were raised for a woman, and then later for another woman, a wife." In my humble opinion this Tyler wants to create and raise kids without female figure.
Based to what I comprehended, it looks like there are two types of female protagonists involved in the neo noir films. Either she plays the role of whom makes men's life miserable and she is see just as sexual object or as the classic noir femme fatale with the difference that she neither died nor change her life style. Such characters can be appreciate in the movie "Fight Club" and "The Last Seduction". Where in the first movie mentioned before, Marla plays the only female persona, a woman that confronts en several occasions the rejection from men. And the other side, The Last Seduction film, Bridget as a femme fatale killed her husband and her lover paid the consequences of such crime. This scenario is as same as classic noir, but here Bridget left without to pay for her evil actions and with money in her packet.
As the quote that Heather Fireman took from Marla San Felippo "The Last Seduction reflects anxieties about current feminist advances, examining masculinity and femininity in light of deconstructed and reconstructed gender roles." Therefore, female characters have something else in their minds than being beautiful, treacherous, and being killed. They play to be alive with glory and money.
Lack of colors versus color films, predatory characters, and different budget are some of the descriptions of Classic Noir and Neo Noir, however the tale of the fisherman and the fish is the same, I think that later on we will see who is the fisherman and who is the prey...
I enjoyed your blog very much, it's quite impressive. The classic noir and Neo noir comparisons and contrasts were very creatively utilized. The use of pictures in the blog gave the words visual aspects that were right on with what was being said. You have a clear understanding on the similarities and differences of the two and you express yourself with catchy phrases and descriptions. If there are people out there reading your blog, that aren't in Mr. Toth's class, or have never seen a classic noir or Neo noir film, I believe they will be drawn in by your convincing blog.
ReplyDeleteMaura, you did an awesome job! Wow! I'm really impressed. You clearly got this whole neo-noir vs. film noir thing in check. I loved how you used pictures within your text to get your meaning across. It helped me to understand it more. I wish I would've read your blog first, before writing my own post. You definetly made it easier for me to understand. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteMaura, I'm very fascinated with the way that you broke down your comprhension based on the article that we read. I really liked how you stated simple facts from the article and put your very own thoughts into it. I also really liked how you put all those pictures to demonstrate your examples for your explanation. Lastly, I have to say GOOD JOB with your quotes. You knew how to place them in and give a brief discription on what they meant and also on what you thought they meant. Great Job Maura and I hope you enjoy reading my comments as much I enjoy reading your blogs. Once again great job and keep up the good work.
ReplyDeletefilm noir and neo-noir practically have the same characteristics like they bring the famme fatale back even though she is not that powerful I strongly agree with the comment above. i like the way you use the pictures with your explanations,they fit just perfect. I also enjoy reading you blog because you make it more understandable and interesting to read,looking forward on reading your next blog keep up the good work, =)
ReplyDeleteGreat Blog!!! You really clearly explained the functions of both genres. As I read the article I honesty didn't see all of the similarities and difference the two film genres possessed. I understood it to a minimum but you really did well in your description of the two. I love the visual affects you incorporated in your blog. With the black and white vs. the photo in color. It added to what your were saying. The title was brilliant as well “Two Faces…..One Coin” I loved it. Many of us just tried to write something just, to complete the assignment but you went above and beyond. Again great job!
ReplyDeleteMaura, you did a great job! I like the way you describe the difference between the two films and how you post pictures to express your understanding. After reading your blog it help me visualize and understand the difference of neo-noir and film noir. I was having difficulty understanding the difference but by viewing your blog I totally understand the difference know. Once again Great Job! and thanks for your insights that help me understand the comparison.
ReplyDeleteHi maura, it was really enjoyable and understable blog. The way you wrote this blog helped me a lot to understand more clearly the idea of the whole thing. I wish I read your blog before I WRITE mine. Anyway, looking forward for your next good work. Great job done!
ReplyDelete